Hawthorne Heights: If Only You Were Lonely Turns 20
By Cait Bennett
November 2, 2026
“It’s not 2006 anymore, but let’s pretend we’re hearing these songs for the first time, tonight,” Hawthorne Heights frontman JT Woodruff reintroduced the crowd to their second studio album, If Only You Were Lonely. New York’s Irving Plaza is the fifth stop on the second leg of the Lonely World Tour. “We finish right before Thanksgiving,” Matt Ridenour told the audience, and I’m sure it’s a welcome reprieve at the tail end of an ambitious touring schedule that began almost a year ago. It’s the albums’ 20 year anniversary, a moment of reflection and celebration for the band and the fans, some of whom have been following the band since their inception.
Hawthorne Heights treated the audience to a complete playthrough of If Only You Were Lonely, showcasing their musical capabilities with explosive refrains and heavy guitars, colored by melodramatic and deeply emotional reflections on a long distance relationship. And these songs hold up well after 20 years. The opening riff of This Is Who We Are filled with tension, the anthemic chorus of Saying Sorry and the haunting imagery of Dead in the Water all serve as solid proof for why this album made it to number 3 on the Billboard 200.
Hawthorne Heights’ endurance in the scene is rooted in their unique fan community. For one fan, Shaun, a Hawthorne Heights show is “a good reason for my fellow emo friends to get together.” This seems to be the vision that frontman JT had going into the night, as he railed against devices and pushed us towards a nostalgic past. “There’s nothing on [the internet] that is better than this, right now… you can get this feeling every day. Put your phone down, crank up songs that matter, and you’ll be alright.”
Beyond their fan community, the band’s reputation amongst their fans is a huge part of the loyal following they’ve built. “They’re angels,” fan Leah said of the band, who she’s been following since their first tour for If Only You Were Lonely, way back in 2006. She had a wealth of stories about her time as a Hawthorne Heights fan, like the time she changed her flight to catch their show and JT thanked her personally from the stage. “I caught a drumstick at one show,” Leah continued, “and they stopped their whole security detail just to sign my stick.” It turns out that good people attract good people.
Even newer fans of Hawthorne Heights find themselves gravitating towards this community. Some fans only heard Hawthorne Heights during their sets at the Vans Warped Tour revival, while others, like Shaun, had been listening for so long that “they were my #1 band on my iPod.” Ohio Is For Lovers, the final song of the band’s encore, has become a classic song on any emo playlist, but that doesn’t undermine the band’s deeper cuts. For Shaun, it was The Translation (which he refers to by the classic lyric “Diamond Eyes”) that saw him “pivot from punk rock to post hardcore.”
I am lucky, I think, to have been in the crowd as Hawthorne Heights played Cross Me Off Your List, yelling alongside countless other fans reacting to the singing guitars crying out for connection. I am lucky to reflect in the somber moments as Decembers closed out the album. “This is a tough one for me,” JT hesitated upon beginning the song, relaying how he recorded this album right after marrying “the love of [his] life, Niki… ‘NikiFM’, you’re all in the room tonight with emo royalty,” a cheer broke out for Niki. The heartbreaking final song of a concept album largely centered on long distance relationships, JT wrote this song in a hotel room missing his new wife. “These,” he choked up, “are the truest words I’ve ever written.”